AT&T vs Verizon: The Ultimate Showdown of Wireless Titans
October 30, 2024
In the high-stakes world of wireless communication, two giants stand tall above the rest: AT&T and Verizon. These telecommunications powerhouses have been battling for supremacy in the US market for years, each vying for your hard-earned dollars with an array of enticing plans, cutting-edge features, and promises of unparalleled connectivity.
But in this sea of options, how do you navigate the choppy waters of data plans, 5G coverage, and their hidden fees and perks selections to find the perfect fit for your mobile needs? Fear not, intrepid phone user! We're about to embark on a deep dive into the AT&T vs Verizon showdown, leaving no stone unturned in our quest to crown a winner.
As two of the largest telecommunications giants in the United States, Verizon and AT&T offer a wide range of prepaid plans catering to diverse needs. This comprehensive comparison will help you navigate the intricacies of their offerings and make an informed decision.
Let the wireless wars begin!Â
1. Data, Talk, and Text Plans Cost Comparison
When it comes to prepaid plans, both Verizon and AT&T offer competitive pricing structures with varying data allowances and features. Let's break down their base plan prices:
First the Verizon Pricing:Â
Feature |
Talk & Text |
15 GB |
Unlimited |
Unlimited Plus |
Monthly Price |
$35 |
$45 |
$60 |
$70 |
AutoPay Discount (After 1 month) |
$30 |
$35 |
$50 |
$60 |
Loyalty Discount (After 3 months) |
- |
$40 |
$55 |
$65 |
Loyalty Discount (After 9 months) |
- |
$35 |
$50 |
$60 |
Multiline Discount |
- |
- |
Get $20 more with each line |
Get $10 more with each line |
5G Ultra Wideband |
- |
- |
- |
✓ |
5G |
- |
✓ |
✓ |
✓ |
4G LTE data |
✓ |
✓ |
✓ |
✓ |
Global Choice |
Add for $10/mo |
Add for $10/mo |
Add for $10/mo |
1 country included with your plan |
Mobile Hotspot |
- |
Share your data when on 5G Nationwide & 4G LTE |
5 GB 4G LTE data, then unlimited lower-speed data |
25 GB premium Mobile Hotspot data, then unlimited lower-speed data |
Unlimited talk & text |
✓ |
✓ |
✓ |
✓ |
International texting |
✓ |
✓ |
✓ |
✓ |
Mexico & Canada talk, text & data |
$5/day |
✓ |
✓ |
✓ |
Call Filter spam blocker |
✓ |
✓ |
✓ |
✓ |
Digital Secure (Basic) |
✓ |
✓ |
✓ |
The following will give a complete overview of the AT&T pricing:
Feature |
5GB data |
8GB data |
15GB data |
Unlimited + 5GB hotspot data |
Price |
$30.00/mo. |
$33.00/mo. |
$40.00/mo. |
$50.00/mo. |
Price details |
Plus taxes and fees |
Plus taxes and fees |
Plus taxes and fees |
With AutoPay.* $55/mo. without AutoPay |
Special conditions |
After high-speed data is used, speed slowed to a max of 128Kbps for rest of term |
When you pay $99 in advance for three months of service. Requires new single line |
After high-speed data is used, speed slowed to a max of 128Kbps for rest of term |
AT&T may temporarily slow data speeds if the network is busy. Req's new line & AutoPay |
Talk & Text |
Unlimited talk, text & 5GB high-speed data |
Unlimited talk, text & 8GB high-speed data |
Unlimited talk, text & 15GB high-speed data |
Unlimited talk, text & high-speed data |
5G access |
Included¹ |
Included¹ |
Included¹ |
Included¹ |
International texting |
Unlimited text from the U.S. to over 230 countries |
Unlimited text from the U.S. to over 230 countries |
Unlimited text from the U.S. to over 230 countries |
Unlimited text from the U.S. to over 230 countries |
Mexico & Canada usage |
Unlimited talk, text & use of plan data in and between the U.S., Mexico & Canada (5G in U.S. only). 2G off-net data speeds may apply |
Unlimited talk, text & use of plan data in and between the U.S., Mexico & Canada (5G in U.S. only). 2G off-net data speeds may apply |
Unlimited talk, text & use of plan data in and between the U.S., Mexico & Canada (5G in U.S. only). 2G off-net data speeds may apply |
Unlimited talk, text & data in and between the U.S., Mexico & Canada. Limit 25GB in Canada, 5G in U.S. only. 2G off-net data speeds may apply |
Security |
AT&T ActiveArmor mobile security². Fraud call blocking & more |
AT&T ActiveArmor mobile security². Fraud call blocking & more |
AT&T ActiveArmor mobile security². Fraud call blocking & more |
AT&T ActiveArmor mobile security². Fraud call blocking & more |
Hotspot |
Hotspot data. Turn your phone into a hotspot. Uses plan data allotment |
Hotspot data. Turn your phone into a hotspot. Uses plan data allotment |
Hotspot data. Turn your phone into a hotspot. Uses plan data allotment |
5GB hotspot data |
Streaming quality |
Standard-definition streaming |
HD streaming available |
Standard-definition streaming |
Standard-definition streaming |
Data rollover |
Rollover Data. Unused data rolls over to the next month |
Rollover Data. Unused data rolls over to the next month |
Rollover Data. Unused data rolls over to the next month |
Not mentioned |
It's important to note that these prices may not include taxes and fees. Both carriers have different policies regarding additional charges:
- Verizon: Typically includes taxes and fees in the advertised price for prepaid plans.
- AT&T: Often charges additional taxes and fees on top of the base plan price.
Both carriers offer unlimited talk and text on all plans. The main differences lie in data allowances and hotspot capabilities.
Going more deep and if try to understand the pricing based on the user needs:
- Entry-level plans:
- AT&T offers more options for low data users with 5GB and 8GB plans.
- Verizon's lowest data plan starts at 15GB, which might be overkill for some users.
- Mid-range plans:
- For 15GB, Verizon is cheaper at $35/mo with AutoPay, compared to AT&T's $40/mo.
- Both offer unlimited plans at $50/mo with AutoPay.
- High-end plans:
- Verizon offers an Unlimited Plus plan with more features, while AT&T's top plan is their standard unlimited.
- Verizon's top plan offers significantly more hotspot data (25GB vs 5GB).
- Long-term value:
- Verizon's loyalty discounts can reduce prices further after 3 and 9 months.
- AT&T doesn't mention loyalty discounts but offers data rollover on limited plans.
- Multi-line discounts:
- Verizon explicitly mentions multi-line discounts for unlimited plans.
- AT&T doesn't specify multi-line discounts in the provided information.
- Additional features:
- Both offer similar international texting and Mexico/Canada usage.
- Verizon includes 5G Ultra Wideband in their top-tier plan.
- AT&T offers HD streaming on their 8GB plan, while Verizon doesn't specify streaming quality.
Verdict: The "winner" in pricing depends on individual needs, but here's a breakdown:
- For low data users (under 15GB), AT&T offers more affordable and flexible options.
- For mid-range users (15GB-Unlimited), Verizon edges out with slightly lower pricing and the potential for loyalty discounts.
- For heavy data users, Verizon's Unlimited Plus plan offers more features (especially hotspot data) at a competitive price.
Overall, Verizon seems to offer slightly better value for money, especially for moderate to heavy data users and those who can take advantage of AutoPay and loyalty discounts. However, AT&T's pricing is more straightforward (taxes and fees included) and offers better options for low data users.
The final choice would depend on individual usage patterns, the importance of specific features (like hotspot data or HD streaming), and whether a user can commit to AutoPay or staying with the carrier long-term to benefit from discounts.
Hidden Fees and Overage Charges
- Verizon charges a $35 activation fee for new lines, while AT&T waives this fee for prepaid customers.
- Both carriers may charge for international calling or roaming if not included in your plan.
- Data overage charges vary:
- Verizon: Reduces speeds after reaching the high-speed data limit.
- AT&T: Offers data add-ons for purchase if you exceed your limit.
Late Payment Policies
- Verizon: Suspends service immediately if payment isn't received by the due date.
- AT&T: Offers a grace period of up to 3 days before suspending service.
Moving forward in our comparison. Let’s find out the speed of both the carriers.Â
2. Network Speed and Data Performance
Network performance can vary significantly based on location and network congestion. However, recent Openignal data suggests:
- Verizon's average download speed experience: 34.3 Mbps
- Verizon's average upload speed experience: 8.3 Mbps
- AT&T's average download speed experience : 40.1 Mbps
- AT&T's average upload speed experience: 6.4 Mbps
While AT&T has a slight edge in overall speed, Verizon often performs better in major cities areas due to its 5G speed.
User Feedback and Third-Party Ratings
According to OpenSignal's July 2023 report:
3. 5G Network and Coverage
5G availability is becoming increasingly important for mobile users:
- Verizon 5G coverage: 65.5% of the U.S.
- AT&T 5G coverage: 81.6% of the U.S.
While AT&T boasts wider 5G coverage, Verizon's 5G Ultra Wideband network often delivers faster speeds in areas where it's available.
4. Perks, Add-Ons, and Unique Features
Both carriers offer various perks to entice customers.
Let's break down the perks offered by both Verizon and AT&T, and then compare them to see which carrier offers better value in terms of additional benefits.
Verizon Perks
Perk |
Monthly Cost |
Notes |
Disney Bundle |
$10/line |
Includes Disney+, Hulu, ESPN+ |
Apple One |
$10/line |
|
Netflix & Max (With Ads) |
$10/line |
|
Apple Music Family |
$10/line |
|
YouTube Premium |
$10/account |
|
+play Monthly Credit |
$10/line |
|
Apple Arcade |
$6.99/line |
6 months free with select plans |
Google Play Pass |
$4.99/account |
6 months free with select plans |
Disney+ Premium (No Ads) |
$13.99/account |
Included with select plans |
Premium Streaming |
$10/line |
|
discovery+ |
$8.99/account |
6 months free with select plans |
YouTube TV |
$62.99 for 12 months, then $72.99 |
For new subscribers, Home Internet customers only |
AT&T Perks
Perk |
Details |
Notes |
Device Protection (Asurion) |
$11.99/month |
Covers loss, theft, damage, out of warranty malfunctions |
AT&T ActiveArmor |
Free |
Blocks fraud calls, alerts for suspected spam |
AutoPay Savings |
Save $15/month |
On Unlimited plans |
Family Plan Discount |
Up to $20 off/month |
|
BridgePay |
Flexible payment option |
For when customers are short on funds |
International Travel Add-On |
$35 for 7 days |
Unlimited talk, text & 5GB of data |
Â
Now, let's compare the perks offered by Verizon and AT&T:
- Entertainment Offerings:
- Verizon offers a wide range of entertainment perks, including Disney Bundle, Apple One, Netflix & Max, YouTube Premium, and discovery+.
- AT&T doesn't mention specific entertainment perks in the provided information.
- Winner: Verizon
- Music Services:
- Verizon offers Apple Music Family.
- AT&T doesn't mention any music service perks.
- Winner: Verizon
- Gaming:
- Verizon provides Apple Arcade and Google Play Pass.
- AT&T doesn't mention any gaming perks.
- Winner: Verizon
- Device Protection:
- AT&T explicitly mentions Asurion device protection for $11.99/month.
- Verizon doesn't mention device protection in the provided perks list.
- Winner: AT&T
- Security Features:
- AT&T offers AT&T ActiveArmor for free.
- Verizon doesn't mention specific security features in the perks list.
- Winner: AT&T
- Savings and Discounts:
- AT&T offers AutoPay savings and family plan discounts.
- Verizon offers a +play Monthly Credit, but doesn't specify general plan discounts.
- Winner: Tie (both offer savings, but in different forms)
- International Travel:
- AT&T offers a specific international travel add-on.
- Verizon doesn't mention international travel perks in the provided list.
- Winner: AT&T
- Flexibility for Payment:
- AT&T offers BridgePay for customers short on funds.
- Verizon doesn't mention a similar feature in the perks list.
- Winner: AT&T
Overall Comparison: Verizon offers a more extensive range of entertainment and content-related perks, which could be very attractive to customers who value streaming services, music, and gaming. These perks, if fully utilized, could represent significant value.
AT&T, on the other hand, focuses more on practical perks like device protection, security features, and flexible payment options. They also offer a specific international travel add-on, which could be valuable for frequent travelers.
Verdict: The "better" offer depends on individual needs and preferences:
- If you're someone who heavily uses entertainment services and would benefit from bundled offerings, Verizon's perks provide better value.
- If you prioritize practical features like device protection, security, and flexible payment options, AT&T's perks might be more appealing.
In terms of sheer number and variety of perks, Verizon appears to offer more. However, AT&T's perks cover some essential areas that Verizon doesn't mention in their list.
Ultimately, the best choice would depend on which perks align more closely with your personal usage patterns and needs. It's also worth noting that the value of these perks should be considered alongside the base plan costs and features when making a decision.
5. Best for Specific Groups
For Students
AT&T offers a $10/mo discount for verified students on their Unlimited plan, making it more attractive for this demographic.
For Travelers
Both carriers offer international add-ons:
- Verizon's TravelPass: $10/day for use of your domestic plan abroad
- AT&T's International Day Pass: $10/day for unlimited talk, text, and data in over 210 countries
For Large Families
AT&T's multi-line discounts on their unlimited prepaid plans often provide better value for large families compared to Verizon's offerings.
6. Contracts, Flexibility, and Device Compatibility
As prepaid plans, neither carrier requires long-term contracts. Both allow you to bring your own device (BYOD) or purchase a new one at full retail price.
Switching between carriers is relatively straightforward, with both offering to help you port your number. However, you may need to ensure your device is compatible with the new network.
7. International Service
For frequent international travelers:
- Verizon offers better high-speed data options in more countries
- AT&T provides more affordable options for talk and text in a larger number of countries
8. Special Discounts and Offers
Both carriers offer discounts for specific groups.
Verizon Military discount:
Plan |
4 lines |
3 lines |
2 lines |
1 line |
Unlimited Ultimate |
$50/line* (Save $5/line) |
$56.67/line* (Save $8.33/line) |
$67.50/line* (Save $12.50/line) |
$80/line* (Save $10/line) |
Unlimited Plus |
$40/line* (Save $5/line) |
$46.67/line* (Save $8.33/line) |
$57.50/line* (Save $12.50/line) |
$70/line* (Save $10/line) |
Unlimited Welcome |
$25/line* (Save $5/line) |
$31.67/line* (Save $8.33/line) |
$42.50/line* (Save $12.50/line) |
$55/line* (Save $10/line) |
*With Auto Pay and paper-free billing. Plus taxes and fees.
Additional discounts:
- Single line: $10/mo account discount
- 2-3 lines: $25/mo account discount
- 4+ lines: $20/mo account discount
Note: 12% off all mobile perks with military discount.
Verizon Special Offers
Offer |
Details |
Military Discount |
• $10/mo discount for single line |
Plan Pricing with Discount |
• Unlimited Welcome: Starting at $25/line for 4 lines |
AT&T Special Offers
Offer |
Details |
Student Discount |
• $10/mo savings on AT&T Prepaid Unlimited plan |
Military, Veterans, and Family Discount |
• 20% off AT&T Prepaid monthly unlimited plan |
Now, let's compare which carrier offers better special discounts:
- Military Discounts:
- Verizon offers tiered discounts based on the number of lines, ranging from $10 to $25 per month, plus 12% off mobile perks.
- AT&T offers a flat 20% discount on their unlimited prepaid plan, reducing the price from $65 to $37 per month.
Verdict: AT&T seems to offer a more substantial discount for military members, especially for single lines. However, Verizon's discount could be more beneficial for multi-line accounts.
- Student Discounts:
- Verizon doesn't mention a specific student discount in the provided information.
- AT&T offers a $10/month discount for students on their Prepaid Unlimited plan.
Verdict: AT&T wins for student discounts.
- Flexibility and Plan Options:
- Verizon offers discounts across multiple plan tiers (Welcome, Plus, Ultimate), allowing for more choice.
- AT&T's discount applies to their Prepaid Unlimited plan only.
Verdict: Verizon offers more flexibility in plan choice with discounts.
- Multi-line Discounts:
- Verizon clearly outlines multi-line discounts, with prices as low as $25/line for 4 lines on the Welcome plan.
- AT&T doesn't specify multi-line discounts for their special offers.
Verdict: Verizon appears to be better for families or groups needing multiple lines.
- Additional Perks:
- Verizon offers 12% off mobile perks with the military discount.
- AT&T doesn't mention additional perks with their discounts.
Verdict: Verizon provides extra value with discounted perks.
Overall, both carriers offer compelling discounts for specific groups. AT&T seems to offer a more straightforward and potentially larger discount for individual military members and students.Â
However, Verizon's discounts appear more flexible and potentially more valuable for multi-line accounts and those who would benefit from discounted perks.
The best choice would depend on individual circumstances, such as the number of lines needed, the desired plan features, and how much value one would get from additional perks. It's also worth noting that these special offers may change over time, so it's always best to check with the carriers directly for the most up-to-date information.
Important Note: Neither carrier offers specific prepaid discounts for seniors
9. Customer Service and RatingÂ
Breaking down the customer support ratings for Verizon and AT&T based on the information provided on many forums, Trustpilot and then comparing them.
Metric |
Verizon |
AT&T |
Number of Reviews |
5,397 |
7,719 |
TrustScore |
1.2 out of 5 |
1.3 out of 5 |
Overall Rating |
Bad |
Bad |
Comparison:
- While both companies have poor ratings for their customer support, AT&T performs marginally better with a 1.3 TrustScore compared to Verizon's 1.2.
- AT&T has received more reviews, which could suggest either a larger customer base or that AT&T customers are more likely to leave reviews (positive or negative).
- The fact that both companies are rated as "Bad" indicates systemic issues in the telecommunications industry regarding customer support.
- AT&T's mention of help videos suggests they might offer more self-service options, which some customers may prefer.
In conclusion, neither company performs well in customer support based on these ratings. AT&T has a slight edge in terms of TrustScore, but the difference is minimal. Both carriers clearly have significant room for improvement in their customer support services.
It's important to note that these ratings represent aggregate experiences and may not reflect individual interactions. Customers may want to consider other factors alongside customer support when choosing between these carriers, such as network coverage, plan pricing, and additional features or perks.
10. AT&T vs Verizon: Is There a Game-Changing Alternative?
While the titans AT&T and Verizon continue their epic battle for wireless supremacy, a new contender has entered the ring, promising to shake up the mobile market. Enter Mingle Mobile, a fresh face in the prepaid mobile service arena that's turning heads with its wallet-friendly plans and customer-centric approach.
Why Mingle Mobile is Making Waves
Imagine getting high-speed 5G internet, unlimited talk and text, and 1GB of data for just $9 a month. Sounds too good to be true? That's exactly what Mingle Mobile is offering, and they're sweetening the deal with a jaw-dropping 80% discount for new customers. But the perks don't stop there:
- Flexibility Galore: Top up premium data or hotspot allowance whenever you need, no strings attached.
- Binge-Worthy Streaming: High-quality video streaming without breaking the bank.
- Freedom First: No contracts, no credit checks, and the ability to cancel anytime – it's wireless on your terms.
- Transparency is Key: Say goodbye to bill shock with no hidden fees and all taxes included.
- Seamless Management: A free, user-friendly app puts you in control of your plan.
- Hassle-Free Setup: Free SIM activation and number porting make switching a breeze.
- Network You Can Trust: Riding on the largest and fastest 5G network in the US (though they don't name it, it's likely one of the big players).
The Mingle Mobile Edge
What sets Mingle Mobile apart is their aggressive pricing strategy. They're currently testing plans with a staggering 80-90% discount for the first month. This bold move allows customers to experience their service at a fraction of the cost, potentially disrupting the traditional carrier model.
Is It Time to Mingle?
If you're feeling underwhelmed by AT&T and Verizon's offerings or simply looking to slash your mobile bill, Mingle Mobile presents an intriguing option. Their no-nonsense approach to pricing, coupled with the use of a top-tier network, makes them a serious contender in the prepaid market.
Whether you're a budget-conscious consumer, a data-hungry streamer, or someone who values flexibility above all, Mingle Mobile's offerings are worth a closer look.
Want to see if it's time to make the switch and start mingling with a new kind of mobile service. Check out the Mingle Mobile pricing and features.
11. Verizon vs AT&T: Additional Services and Flexibility
Both carriers offer:
- Smartwatch plans
- Mobile hotspot capabilities (varies by plan)
- Wi-Fi calling
Verizon tends to offer more customization options for add-ons, while AT&T's plans are often more straightforward.
12. Conclusion: Which Carrier is Right for You?
Choosing between Verizon and AT&T prepaid plans depends on your specific needs:
- For budget-conscious users: AT&T's prepaid plans often provide more data at lower price points.
- For those seeking the fastest 5G: Verizon's 5G Ultra Wideband, where available, offers blazing speeds.
- For travelers: AT&T's international options are generally more affordable and flexible.
- For large families: AT&T's multi-line discounts on unlimited prepaid plans offer excellent value.
- For rural users: AT&T's network often performs better in less populated areas.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your location, data needs, budget, and personal preferences. Consider trying out both carriers' services if possible, as real-world performance can vary significantly from advertised claims.
Remember to regularly review your plan and usage to ensure you're getting the best value for your money. The mobile landscape is constantly evolving, with new plans and features being introduced regularly. Stay informed and don't hesitate to switch if a better option becomes available.